A Question of Fairness and the PCAOB
Written by Bob Scott   
Wednesday, 05 January 2011 03:03

Last month, the Public Company Oversight Board reported that it had censured a CPA working at an Ernst & Young office. The board took the action because the audit partner and a manager instructed the young woman to put backdated items into a clients audit workpapers. But despite noting more than once that the more senior members of the team gave these orders, the PCAOB didn't name them.

More than one reader suggested this young CPA, Jacqueline Higgins, who was part of the audit team, was hung out to dry. And it raises that old question of what an employee does when the boss orders them to do something wrong. Unfortunately, the PCAOB action doesn't tell the rest of the story.

Because I am not intricately familiar with how the enforcement process took place, I'm not sure there is more that should have been done. But the language concerning what happened  that drew the censure is clear: "The Engagement Partner and the Senior Manager subsequently directed Respondent improperly to remove, add, and backdate
documents in the external working papers."

The PCAOB then cited four separate instances of documents that were incorrectly subject to these actions. Twice this action was taken at the instruction of the engagement partner, once at the direction of the senior manager and once both gave the word. As mentioned the names of the two senior staff members didn't appear and there's no suggestion in the PCAOB order that these two have been suggested to any review.

Again, maybe there's something in this process that I understand. But it sure doesn't look right.

 

 

 

 


Bob Scott
About the author:
Bob Scott has provided information to the tax and accounting community since 1991, first as technology editor of Accounting Today, and from 1997 through 2009 as editor of its sister publication, Accounting Technology. He is known throughout the industry for his depth of knowledge and for his high journalistic standards.  
Read More >>
Last Updated on Friday, 07 January 2011 18:52
 

Add your comment

Your name:
Your email:
Subject:
Comment:
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification:

Intuit's Smith: Good Tax Season; But..

News image

  Intuit had an 11 percent increase in consumer tax revenue and the first growth in units sold to tax preparation professionals in three years for its third quarter ended April 30. But CEO Brad Smith thought the company should have done better in both areas in what he called a solid performance..  

News | Bob Scott | Friday, 18 May 2012

Wave Accounting Gets $12 Million

News image

Wave Accounting has secured $12 million in funding for its efforts to develop the market for its online accounting applications. Based in Toronto, Wave said the funding round was led by The Social+Capital Partnership with participation from existing investors Charles River Ventures and OMERS Venture.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Thursday, 17 May 2012

NetSuite Signs GT, Deloitte, Frank Rimerman

NetSuite is making strong inroads into the accounting community. At its SuiteWorld conference, underway this week in San Francisco, it announced three accounting firms and Sage's largest reseller as new additions to its channel.

News | Bob Scott | Tuesday, 15 May 2012

A Cloudy Year for Accounting Software

The technology press likes to declare something a "Year of ..." whatever the hottest trend is. But evidence is building that 2012 is going to be a big year for the sale of accounting applications that run on the web. Now, as is usually the case, there are usually a few big years once a new technology catches on.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Tuesday, 15 May 2012

SmartPros Results Flat

News image

Continuing education provider Smart Pros turned in results for its first quarter ended March 31 that showed both revenue and its net loss virtually unchanged from results in 2011. The company said lingering results from the recession and competitive factors kept a lid of its business.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Tuesday, 15 May 2012

TaxAct Revs Up 9 Percent

News image

TaxAct, the tax preparation software company purchased by InfoSpace, had pro forma revenue of $61.9 million a 9-percent increase from $56.8 million for the first quarter ended March 31. TaxAct, purchased on January 31 contributed only two months of actual results to its Bellevue, Wash.-based parent.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Thursday, 10 May 2012

Sage and Avalara Ally for Accountants Network

News image

Sales-and-use tax vendor Avalara is joining with Sage North America to provide resources to members of the Sage Accountants Network. Avalara's Accountants Resource Center provides tools and educational resources for helping them increase their sales tax knowledge.  

News | The Progressive Accountant | Tuesday, 8 May 2012

CliftonLarsonAllen to Resell Avectra

News image

CliftonLarsonAllen has agreed to resell Avectra's Social CRM to associations and nonprofit organizations.The accounting firm will offer the Avectra product in combination with Intacct's online accounting software. It is the latest move in the expansion of McLean, Va.-based Avectra's reseller program.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Thursday, 3 May 2012

ADP Revenue and Net Up 7 Percent for 2012

News image

Automatic Data Processing rolled sevens for its fiscal 2012 as net income, and revenue for employer services and total revenue all increased by 7 percent over 2011. And the company's metrics were strong in almost all areas for the year just ended.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Thursday, 3 May 2012

CompuPay Folds into BenefitMall

News image

Austin Ventures has led a round of equity financing that merged BenefitMall, which provides employee benefit plans through a broker network, and CompuPay, a payroll services and software provided. Terms were not disclosed. The payroll operations are now known as CompuPay, a BenefitMall company.

News | The Progressive Accountant | Wednesday, 2 May 2012

More in: News